Caffarelli & Associates LtD

News

1 minute read

Mystery Employee Defacates on Floor – Company Cannot Require DNA Tests to Find Culprit

Published

In a case she described as the “mystery of the devious defacator,” Judge Amy Totenberg of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia in Atlanta ruled that a Company could not require employees to take a DNA test to determine whether they were defacating on the Company’s warehouse floor. To do so, reasoned Judge Totenberg, violates the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (“GINA”), 42 U.S.C. § 2000ff, et seq., which generally prohibits employers from requesting genetic information from its employees.
In this case, the Company, Atlas Logistics Group Retail Services, requested that two employees submit to saliva swabs of their cheeks to determine whether either of their DNA matched the DNA found in the feces. The employees complied but later sued — neither of them came up as a DNA match — claiming that Atlas violated GINA. Having found in favor of the plaintiffs with regard to liability, the case will now proceed to the damages phase. You can read the decision here: http://justiceatwork.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Order.pdf
UPDATE — the jury awarded the two employees $2.2 Million!

Back to News

Recent Posts

Blog

Whitney L. Barr’s Article “Gender Violence in the Workplace” Published in the Illinois Bar Journal

Caffarelli & Associates Ltd. is pleased to highlight an article by associate Whitney L. Barr, published in the Illinois Bar Journal, titled “Gender Violence in the Workplace.” The piece explores the 2024 amendments to the Illinois Gender Violence Act, which expand legal protections for victims of sexual assault, harassment, and other forms of gender-related violence in the workplace. Ms. Barr explains how these updates strengthen accountability and clarify employer liability under Illinois employment law, marking a major development in employee rights and workplace safety....

Read More
Blog

Protecting Performers: Lessons from ‘Drag Law’ and the Illinois Freelance Worker Protection Act

Amanda Burns from our office had the privilege of presenting at the Lawyers for the Creative Arts event “Drag Law: Werk the Law” on September 30, 2025. The event focused on intellectual property rights of drag performers, contracting rights of performers, and looked at recent litigation surrounding drag performers as it related to intellectual property and payment issues. This event featured performances by two local Chicago drag artists Coco Sho-Nell and Lúc Ami. Amanda’s portion of the event focused on...

Read More
Blog

New Legal Protections: Reproductive Health Decisions

As of January 1, 2025, Illinois law now protects employees and job applicants from discrimination based on their reproductive health decisions. This means you have the right to bring a claim if your employer takes adverse action against you because of choices related to: Birth control or contraception Fertility treatment or sterilization care Assisted reproductive technologies (such as IVF) Miscarriage management Abortion Pregnancy-related healthcare, including prenatal and postnatal care These protections apply to both current employees and prospective employees during...

Read More