Caffarelli & Associates LtD

News

1 minute read

Mystery Employee Defacates on Floor – Company Cannot Require DNA Tests to Find Culprit

Published

In a case she described as the “mystery of the devious defacator,” Judge Amy Totenberg of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia in Atlanta ruled that a Company could not require employees to take a DNA test to determine whether they were defacating on the Company’s warehouse floor. To do so, reasoned Judge Totenberg, violates the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (“GINA”), 42 U.S.C. § 2000ff, et seq., which generally prohibits employers from requesting genetic information from its employees.
In this case, the Company, Atlas Logistics Group Retail Services, requested that two employees submit to saliva swabs of their cheeks to determine whether either of their DNA matched the DNA found in the feces. The employees complied but later sued — neither of them came up as a DNA match — claiming that Atlas violated GINA. Having found in favor of the plaintiffs with regard to liability, the case will now proceed to the damages phase. You can read the decision here: http://justiceatwork.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Order.pdf
UPDATE — the jury awarded the two employees $2.2 Million!

Back to News

Recent Posts

Blog

Illinois Appellate Court Clarifies Employer Liability and Pleading Standards Under the Gender Violence Act

In a significant decision for employees across Illinois, the First District Appellate Court in Doe v. TK Behavioral, LLC, 2026 IL App (1st) 251028, clarified both the scope of employer liability and the pleading standards under the Illinois Gender Violence Act (GVA). This ruling is particularly important for claims involving workplace sexual assault and gender-based violence in Chicago and throughout Illinois, as it confirms that the statute provides meaningful protections beyond traditional common law limitations. In Doe v. TK Behavioral,...

Read More
Blog

April is Sexual Assault Awareness Month – a time to raise awareness, support survivors, and reaffirm our commitment to accountability and justice.

Caffarelli & Associates is dedicated to advocating for individuals who have experienced sexual harassment and assault in the workplace and beyond. We understand the courage it takes to come forward, and we are here to provide compassionate and experienced representation every step of the way. If you or someone you know has been affected, we encourage you to seek support and learn more about your rights and options.

Read More
Blog

Illinois Supreme Court Expands Pay Rights for Pre-Shift Work Under Wage Law

In a major win for Illinois workers, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled that employees may be entitled to pay for required pre-shift and post-shift activities—even when federal law would not require compensation. The landmark ruling strengthens employee rights to compensation for required workplace activities. In Johnson v. Amazon.com Services, LLC, the court addressed whether the Illinois Minimum Wage Law adopts a major limitation from federal law that excludes certain “preliminary” and “postliminary” activities from paid time. The court answered no....

Read More