Caffarelli & Martin Ltd

News

1 minute read

Mystery Employee Defacates on Floor – Company Cannot Require DNA Tests to Find Culprit

Published

In a case she described as the “mystery of the devious defacator,” Judge Amy Totenberg of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia in Atlanta ruled that a Company could not require employees to take a DNA test to determine whether they were defacating on the Company’s warehouse floor. To do so, reasoned Judge Totenberg, violates the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (“GINA”), 42 U.S.C. § 2000ff, et seq., which generally prohibits employers from requesting genetic information from its employees.
In this case, the Company, Atlas Logistics Group Retail Services, requested that two employees submit to saliva swabs of their cheeks to determine whether either of their DNA matched the DNA found in the feces. The employees complied but later sued — neither of them came up as a DNA match — claiming that Atlas violated GINA. Having found in favor of the plaintiffs with regard to liability, the case will now proceed to the damages phase. You can read the decision here: http://justiceatwork.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Order.pdf
UPDATE — the jury awarded the two employees $2.2 Million!

Back to News

Recent Posts

Blog

All Caffarelli & Martin Ltd. Attorneys Recognized by SuperLawyers

We are proud to announce that every attorney at Caffarelli & Martin Ltd. has been recognized by Illinois Super Lawyers for 2027. Partners Alejandro Caffarelli and Alexis Martin were selected to the 2027 Illinois Super Lawyers list, while associates Whitney Barr and Amanda Burns were named 2027 Illinois Rising Stars. Super Lawyers recognizes no more than 5% of attorneys in each state, and Rising Stars recognizes no more than 2.5% of eligible attorneys. Having our entire team honored is both...

Read More
Blog

Caffarelli & Martin Secures Class Certification in Biometric Privacy Case Against Aimbridge

Caffarelli & Martin, Ltd. (p/k/a Caffarelli & Associates) is pleased to announce a significant victory for Illinois workers in Gutierrez v. Aimbridge Employee Service Corp. and Aimbridge Hospitality, LLC. On June 2, 2026, Judge Caroline Kate Moreland of the Circuit Court of Cook County granted Plaintiffs’ renewed motion for class certification in a lawsuit brought under the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act, commonly known as BIPA. The case concerns Aimbridge-managed hotels in Illinois that allegedly required employees to use UltiPro...

Read More
Blog

Caffarelli & Martin Ltd. Secures Unanimous Jury Verdict in Sexual Harassment Case Against El Milagro

Caffarelli & Martin Ltd. is proud to announce a trial victory on behalf of Lilia Carrillo in her hostile work environment sexual harassment case against El-Milagro, Inc. d/b/a El Milagro under the Illinois Human Rights Act. After a five-day jury trial in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois, the jury unanimously found in favor of the Plaintiff. The case was tried by Alejandro Caffarelli and Whitney Barr of Caffarelli & Martin Ltd. Ms. Carrillo worked for a placement company,...

Read More